In ELA, we are currently reading "Romeo and Juliet" by William Shakespeare. Romeo and Juliet is about a young boy and girl from two enemy households (Romeo: Montague, Juliet: Capulet), who fall madly in love, and in a horrible mix up, both end up killing themselves. While reading this script, I noticed a certain theme. Throughout the text, there is a lot of reference to people "coming of age", and reminiscing over children growing up too fast.
Shortly after the initial fight scene, Paris talks to Capulet about his wishes to marry Juliet. To Capulet, he says, "Younger than she are happy mothers made." By this, Paris is saying that girls younger than her are happily married and have children, so Juliet should be perfectly fine with it. In response, Capulet says, "And too soon marred are those so early made." By "made", Capulet means "married", and he is saying that by getting married so soon, Juliet will lose the freedom of life too soon, and it should be lost later in life (in adulthood). They clearly disagree.
When Lady Capulet is first talking to Juliet about marriage, Lady Capulet and Nurse are talking about Juliet's age. Lady Capulet says, "She's not fourteen". "I'll lay fourteen of my teeth (and yet, to my teen be it spoken, I have but four) she's not fourteen," agrees Nurse. At the same time however, they are reminiscing. Nurse goes on a long, ranting story of when Juliet was just a child; "'Tis since the earthquake now eleven years, / And she was weaned (I never shall forget it)/ Of all the days of the year, upon that day...." In this manner, it appears as if Juliet is growing up very fast, and that they are saying that she is young. Soon after, however, Lady Capulet proposes the idea of marriage to Juliet, and tells her of Paris's wish to marry her. When Juliet says that she respects the idea of marriage, but does not wish it for herself just yet, her mother replies, "Younger than you/Here in Verona, ladies of esteem,/Are made already mothers. By my count/I was your mother much upon these years/That you are now a maid." By this, Lady Capulet is saying that at age 13, Juliet should be glad to be a mother; respectable women were mothers at ages younger than 13, and Lady Capulet herself was a mother at around Juliet's age. By these words, it seems as if Lady Capulet is pushing Juliet to become more mature then (in my opinion) she ought to be at such a young age. All of these conflicting messages both support the concept of my theme.
In Act 1, Scene 5, at the party, Capulet is talking to his Cousin about
how long it's been since they last attended a masquerade party.
Capulet's Cousin says it's been thirty years, but Capulet is saying it
hasn't been that long: "Some five and twenty years, and then we masked."
His cousin then replies, "'Tis more, 'tis more. His son is elder, sir.
His son is thirty." To which Capulet replies, "Will you tell me that?/
His son was but a ward (one under the care of a guardian) two years
ago." Capulet is saying that time has gone by very quickly, and he cannot believe how fast "his" son has grown. Although this is a minor detail within the story (barely), it still stood out to me, because there's quite a lot of talk of children/teenagers becoming, or not yet becoming adults.
In class, we're often told to consider why Romeo and Juliet fell so madly in love, and if we think it was smart for their relationship to escalate so quickly as it did. While thinking about the theme that I noticed, I came to a realization. Many people say that Romeo and Juliet's love for each other was just lust, and that it happened way too quickly, and at too young an age. But really, how can we blame them? Throughout the story, there are so many conflicting pieces of advice, or orders about how to act, and what actions should be done in affiliation with their ages. It is true, they do agree to be married very shortly after they meet each other, but what about Paris and Juliet? Do they know each other any better than Romeo and Juliet know each other? Put yourself in Juliet's shoes. Here she is, constantly being told that she is an adult, but also often being defended as a child/teenager. Then, she learns she is soon to be forced to get married to an adult man. Then comes along Romeo, someone actually her age, and they fall in love. Was it really that unwise, or that ridiculous? They're constantly handed responsibilities as adults, and relationship-wise treated like adults, so it was quite understandable that they fell in love as adults, or that they felt they did. Maybe it wasn't just Romeo and Juliet being careless and impulsive, maybe it was how they were treated that made them act the way they did.
Hello Venice! I think this is a very insightful inference. I've certainly been wondering how/why Romeo and Juliet fell in love so quickly. It may not be entirely their faults. Would Juliet have agreed to marry Romeo so fast if she hadn't been promised to Paris? If Romeo hadn't been getting over a heartbreak, would he have run to the first pretty girl he saw? I certainly agree with your views on their love/lust/something.
ReplyDeletegreat post! when i first realized Romeo and Juliet were only thirteen, and pressured into marriage, I was kind of shocked. You cant just take your thirteen year old children and say here, go get married and have kids. I didn't think about it that way, but it makes sense that Romeo and Juliet were attracted to each other, just because they were the same age, and being pressured into similar situations. It makes sense that, since they were being treated like adults, they would make adult decisions.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a great post! I agree with you. I originally never thought about it this way. Romeo and Juliet were told to fall in love, so they did. I think that there's also a sense of rebellion on Juliet's part. She's already unsure about her marriage with Paris, so maybe she was keeping her eyes open to other options just so she could know that Paris is the right decision. The second she found someone slightly better, she went for him, otherwise she would be stuck with Paris and regret not ever finding out who that stranger was.
ReplyDeleteThis is great! I especially agree with your last paragraph. People make hasty decisions when they're pressured from many angles. However, it does seem extremely strange for people to be married at our age. There is so much that I'm looking forward to in my life, and it's crazy to think about people who are tied down and married right now. I consider myself a child, so it's insane to be thinking about people my age raising children.
ReplyDeleteI love your post Venice! It really made me think more into what the story is actually about. I think that the reason why the adults rush their children into marriage so quickly is because they know they only have control over their lives for a certain amount of time and they don't want them making any 'mistakes' but that's not fair at all. You should be allowed to love who ever you want to love, not who your parents say it's okay to be in love with. <3
ReplyDeleteI think part of the reason that Juliet ended up aligning with Romeo when Tybalt got killed is because she didn't want to marry Paris. If she had forgotten about Romeo, her father would have made her marry. He was sort of her last hope at getting what she wanted in terms of love.
ReplyDelete